Choosing French Immersion or English

The task

Your cousin Leila lives in Ottawa. Her daughter starts kindergarten next September, and Leila has to choose between a French immersion program and the regular English program. Nobody in the family speaks French at home. Advise Leila on how to make this decision.

• Read the task, prepare during the preparation time, then speak aloud for the speaking time.
• This is an original practice question written in a CELPIP-style format. It is not a real test question.
• The CLB level of each model answer was reviewed by a TESOL-certified instructor. It is not an official CELPIP score. This practice material is not affiliated with or endorsed by Paragon Testing Enterprises.
• CELPIP is a registered trademark of Paragon Testing Enterprises. This site is not affiliated with Paragon Testing Enterprises.

Preparation

30 seconds

Speaking time

90 seconds

Question

3 of 10

Okay Leila, this is a big decision, and I think there is no, no one right answer. Many families choose French immersion even nobody speak French at home, so don't worry too much about this. But ask the school how they help the parents. Maybe you can't help her with the homework in French. Your daughter. Is she, um, does she like new things? If she likes challenge, immersion can be good for her. If she is shy or she has some problem with speaking, maybe the English program is more easy for her. Visit both schools, I think this is the best thing. They usually have open house, you can talk to the teachers and other parents there. Distance also. A long bus ride is hard for a small kid. And if it doesn't work, she can change later, it's not forever. So yeah, think about it, there's still time.

Why this answer works

• Covers the main factors (home language, the child, a visit, distance), but some arrive as fragments ("Your daughter.", "Distance also.") rather than being weighed against each other.
• Plain vocabulary with natural slips ("even nobody speak French", "more easy") and two restarts ("there is no, no one right answer", "Is she, um, does she like new things?"), as expected at a CLB 7.
• The ending ("So yeah, think about it") is friendly but vague, with no concrete next step.

Leila, it's great that you're thinking about this early. There isn't one right answer, but here are a few things I'd look at. First, don't worry too much that nobody speaks French at home. Lots of families are in the same situation. Still, ask the school what help they give parents, especially with reading and homework. Second, think about your daughter's personality. If she likes new challenges and makes friends easily, immersion could be a good fit. If she's quiet or finds new situations hard, the English program might be more comfortable for her. The most useful step, I think, is to visit both schools. Most schools have an open house, and you can talk to the teachers and ask other parents how their kids are doing. For example, my neighbour's son started immersion last year, and she says the first few months were tiring, but he's happy now. Also remember that the decision isn't permanent. Children can switch programs later. Do you want to look at the school board website with me this weekend?

Why this answer works

• Simple, clear structure: the language worry, her daughter, a visit, and a reminder that the choice can change.
• One real example ("my neighbour's son started immersion last year") makes the advice believable.
• Marks the key step plainly ("The most useful step, I think") and ends with a friendly, specific offer.

Leila, if I were you, I'd lean towards immersion, but only if the school can show you how it supports parents who don't speak French. That's really the deciding question. Think of it as two bets. With immersion, you're betting that your daughter picks up a second language while she's young enough for it to feel like play, and that some homework stress at home is manageable. With the English program, you're betting on comfort now and maybe a French class later, which usually gets a lot less out of the same years. So the bigger payoff is with immersion. The obvious objection is, what happens when she brings home a French reader and you can't help? Ask that exact question at the info night. Some schools run homework clubs or send home audio versions of the books. If their answer's vague, that tells you something. And if she's really struggling by grade one, moving to English is common and won't hold her back. You're not choosing forever, you're choosing a starting point. Which school's info night comes up first?

Why this answer works

• States a conditional recommendation at once ("I'd lean towards immersion, but only if..."), then frames the choice as "two bets" and ranks them.
• Raises and answers the obvious objection about French homework, then gives a fallback ("moving to English is common").
• Precise, natural phrasing ("the deciding question", "won't hold her back", "a starting point") with a closing question that moves her to act.