Celpip.meCelpip.me

Speaking Task 5: Comparing and Persuading

Speaking Task 5: Comparing and Persuading is part of the Speaking section of the CELPIP General test. You get 60 seconds to prepare and 60 seconds to speak. It is scored on Content / Coherence, Vocabulary, Listenability, Task Fulfillment.

Preparation
60 seconds
Speaking time
60 seconds
Prompts here
25 published

The three-move case

  1. 1

    Choose in the first sentence

    You are persuading someone. Deciding out loud for twenty seconds is not persuasion.

  2. 2

    Lead with your strongest reason and name it

    Our CLB 11 answer says "the strongest argument is depreciation" and then explains it. The CLB 5 says "because is more cheap".

  3. 3

    Name the other option's real weakness

    A weakness you invent is worse than none. Use something visible in the options you were given.

Name your best reason; do not make them find it.

Signposting a reason is what turns two facts into an argument.

Sharpen the comparison structures and persuasive language you need to choose between two options and convince your listener in CELPIP Speaking Task 5.

You compare two choices, pick one and persuade someone to agree. Combine comparatives (better, more reliable) with persuasive connectors (the main reason, what really matters) to build a convincing case.

What raters reward here
  • State your choice immediately.
  • Give two strong, detailed reasons.
  • Point out the weakness of the other option.
  • Sound confident.
Three mistakes that cost points heremost common first
  1. 1Comparing the two options feature by feature and never choosing.
  2. 2Attacking the other option more than you support your own.
  3. 3Forgetting there is a listener with a decision to make.
How Speaking is scored
Content / Coherence
Whether your ideas are relevant, developed and logically ordered.
Vocabulary
The range and accuracy of your word choice under time pressure.
Listenability
How easy you are to follow as speech: grammar, flow, pacing, pauses and fillers.
Task Fulfillment
Whether you answered the actual question and covered what was asked.
Model answersthe same prompt, four levels

These are the answers our scorer was calibrated against. Reading a CLB 5 beside a CLB 11 for the same prompt is the fastest way to see what a level actually means. CLB 9 is marked as the target because it is the level that earns maximum language points for Express Entry.

CLB 583 words

Um, I think you should buy the used car, the B one. Because is more cheap. Only nineteen thousand, and the new car is thirty-four thousand, that is very expensive. For a first car is too much money, I think. Um... my cousin he buy a used car too and is fine, no problem. And this car is only three years old, so is not old, and the dealer give a warranty. So yeah. I think the used one is better. Is cheaper.

CLB 7107 words

Okay, so I think you should buy the used car, option B. The main reason is the price. It's nineteen thousand five hundred and the new one is thirty-four thousand, so you save a lot of money. That's a big difference, especially for a first car. And it's not really an old car, um, it only has forty-five thousand kilometres and it comes with a warranty from the dealer for one year. So you don't have to worry too much if something break. The new car has better technology, that's true, but you don't need all that. I think option B is the better car for you.

CLB 9target127 words

I'd definitely go with option B, the certified pre-owned one. The main reason is money. It's nineteen five instead of thirty-four thousand, and remember, a new car lose a big part of its value as soon as you drive it off the lot. So with option A you're basically paying an extra fifteen thousand and then watching that money disappear. The used one has only forty-five thousand kilometres, which is pretty low for three years, and because it's certified, the dealer already checked it and gave a year of warranty with it. The technology is a bit older, sure, but for a first car the important thing is that it's reliable and it doesn't cost you too much money. That's why I'd say go with option B.

CLB 11145 words

If I were in your shoes, I'd go with option B, the certified pre-owned, without much hesitation. The strongest argument is depreciation. That thirty-four thousand dollar car will shed several thousand in its first couple of years, so a big share of what you pay simply evaporates while it sits in your driveway. Option B has already taken that hit for you — the previous owner absorbed the worst of it, and you get in at nineteen five. And it's hardly worn out. Forty-five thousand kilometres over three years is light use, and certification means it's been inspected and backed by a year of dealer coverage. Yes, you give up the newest safety and fuel-saving features, but the gap between a three-year-old model and today's is honestly pretty narrow. Put the difference toward insurance and savings instead. For a first car, that's the wiser call.

Now do it yourself and find out where you land

A model answer shows you the target. It cannot tell you whether your own response hits it — that is a CLB level for each criterion, with the sentences that earned it.

Ready to practise for real?

Get exam-style questions, instant AI feedback on your Writing and Speaking, and a personalised path to your target CLB.

Create your free account →
See pricing
Questions people ask
Do I need to mention both options in Task 5?
Yes. Acknowledge both choices with comparison language, then justify your pick with persuasive reasons. The contrast is what the task is testing.
How do I sound persuasive without sounding aggressive?
Use the softer persuasive phrases below to frame your reasons confidently while staying polite and reasonable.
The other 24 Comparing & Persuading prompts1 free
  • ·Choosing a summer vacation rental
  • ·Choosing a Concert to Attend
  • ·Choosing a new family vehicle
  • ·Choosing an Electric Bicycle
  • ·Choosing a backyard renovation
  • ·Choosing a Barbecue for the Backyard
  • ·Comparing and Persuading
  • ·Choosing a home security system
  • ·Choosing a new office printer
  • ·Choosing an apartment to buy
  • ·Choosing a family vacation
  • ·Choosing a recreation centre
  • ·Hiring a landscaper
  • ·Choosing a scooter for your son
  • ·Choosing a sofa set
  • ·Living Downtown vs Suburbs
  • ·Choosing a new cell phone
  • ·Online vs In-Person Courses
  • ·Saving vs Spending a Bonus
  • ·Public Library vs Buying Books
  • ·Cooking at Home vs Eating Out
  • ·A Big Party vs a Small Gathering
  • ·E-Bike vs Transit Pass
  • ·Choosing a Summer Camp
← All free practiceComparing & Persuading lesson →Comparing & Persuading vocabulary →CELPIP Speaking format →Full mock exams →